Hanky Panky Cocktail

November 15th, 2010  |  Published in amaro, fall, gin, liqueur, recipes, seasonal, thanksgiving  |  6 Comments

In my last post I mentioned that our Thanksgiving cocktail coverage is going to be broken up into three segments (before, during and after dinner) but here I am, drink in hand, ready to present you with a cocktail that transgresses those boundaries. The Hanky Panky is singular, unlikely and delicious, and it provides a window onto one of the great cocktail bars and one of the great, forgotten bartenders. A little bit aperitif, a little bit with-dinner—it manages the neat trick of being a little bit country and a little bit rock ‘n’ roll.

By now many readers are familiar with Harry Craddock’s famous Savoy Cocktail Book of 1930, which has been superbly documented by Erik Ellestad. The book illustrates why the Savoy Hotel in London became an icon of cocktail culture, but Craddock’s notoriety has overshadowed the bartender who was the true face of the Savoy’s legendary American Bar. That bartender was Ada “Coley” Coleman, the woman who helmed the Savoy’s program at the height of its popularity.

Though the recipe for the Hanky Panky is included in the Savoy, most people are put off by the list of ingredients—being as they are fairly improbable—and the drink fell from memory. Ada is better known these days than she was before the re-publication of Ted Haigh’s Vintage Spirits and Forgotten Cocktails, wherein he revived the recipe for a new generation of cocktail enthusiasts. Regardless of where you find the recipe, however, it remains a fine cocktail even today—as well as a fine way to remember and be thankful for the pioneering efforts of ladies like Ada who slugged it out behind the bar when there were no female bartenders.

1½ oz gin
1½ oz sweet vermouth
2 dashes Fernet Branca
twist of orange peel

Stir all ingredients well in an ice-filled shaker and strain into a cocktail glass. Expel a bit of orange oil from the peel over the top of the drink , garnish with the twist and serve.

I probably lost you at sweet vermouth, and those of you who hung on through Fernet Branca are likely long gone by now. Yes, I know, it sounds dreadful in principle but this is a case where the whole is so much more than the sum of its parts. The powerfully herbaceous flavors of the Fernet don’t tend to play well in cocktails, but here they assume the role usually assumed by bitters and marry the sweet and dry of the gin and vermouth. The orange oil adds a delightfully aromatic note that tops the entire cocktail—like the cherry on a sundae—and turns this into a savory, bright drink that makes a delightful complement to any part of the dinner hour.

Note: You still have two days to enter our Pre-Holiday Giveaway! We’re closing it up Thursday, November 18 at midnight PST, so get those emails in now. Good luck!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...


  1. DJ HawaiianShirt says:

    November 16th, 2010at 9:57 am(#)

    Versions of a drink I “created” keep popping up everywhere, like this one! I made a post about it: http://spiritedremix.blogspot.com/2010/07/cocktails-ego.html

    I totally consider the dashes of Fernet to be a suitable replacement for bitters.

  2. Matt Konrad says:

    November 16th, 2010at 12:00 pm(#)

    Ah, what a great drink. Had a night last week devoted to these and one of Craddock’s other greats, the Cabaret. I love the Savoy drinks I’ve seen revived, for being assertive and weird but perfectly balanced.

  3. Marleigh says:

    November 17th, 2010at 8:46 am(#)

    DJ: Fernet—or any amaro, really—can be a great replacement for bitters. I’ve long ago given up pretending that any drink I “make up” is original unless it uses some brand-spanking-new ingredient (and even then, it’s probably based on a classic). Fortunately, I have no aspirations toward being a bartender!

    Matt: This is a good ‘un, but keep Ada in mind when you’re drinking Savoy cocktails—Craddock worked under her, and so some of the original drinks he put to paper were created by her or one of the earlier bartenders who ran the American Bar. Do you read Erik’s blog? He has some great insights and research about the Savoy cocktails he’s revived.

  4. Rick says:

    November 17th, 2010at 4:26 pm(#)

    This cocktail is so ridiculously good and has been on my cocktail menus for parties for all of Fall.

  5. Matt Konrad says:

    November 18th, 2010at 6:17 am(#)

    Marleigh: Absolutely! Dr. Cocktail’s ode to Ada was, to be perfectly honest, the only thing that got me past the dodgy-sounding ingredient list to actually make the drink.

    I’ve only just scratched the surface of Erik’s work, but I’m consistently impressed.

  6. Around the Boozosphere : Liquor Locusts says:

    November 20th, 2010at 1:04 pm(#)

    [...] The Hanky Panky Cocktail. Nice. Looks like the perfect drink for Thanksgiving. Tasty, and a couple of these and you will be hitting on your cousin – Sloshed [...]

SLOSHED! is a website about cocktails and spirits. We can help you find a cocktail, fill you in on products, help you create a new cocktail or even tell you how to start your own home bar. If you like what you see, you can also follow us on Facebook or keep up with new posts via Twitter.

Tweet, Tweet

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

tweet, tweet

Error: Twitter did not respond. Please wait a few minutes and refresh this page.

Find a Cocktail By:


We are part of the Foodbuzz Network